How do you decide what books to buy?
I always seem to have too many books waiting to be read, and ever growing lists of things I want to read which I now keep on GoodReads. This list is ever increasing by writers whom I’ve come to know in person and online and whose work I want to read, but I’ve set limits on when I can buy books. I only get them when I am down to 2 or fewer unread books in a genre. Even with that I cheat sometimes and I’m overwhelmed with books!!!!
And yet, I still want your book and your book and your book….
How do you guys decide what to read? Book reviews? Blogs? Word of mouth? Readings/signings?




Kevin D
March 6, 2010
Hi Jessie,
I buy books a lot from a poems I read out in the wild (i.e. blogs, lit journals, word of mouth, and readings). I don’t think I’ve ever bought a book based on a review. Surprisingly though, I think, there are a bunch of books I’ve bought just from browsing used bookstores and seeing a name I recognize. In very rare instances I’ll see a book cover so awesome that I have to buy the book.
Jessie Carty
March 7, 2010
Ya know, I wonder about reviews too Kevin. I have rarely ever bought a book based on a review unless it had a particularly striking quote.
There is nothing better than scoring a book just because you recognized the name! I was floored to find Van Jordan’s first book “Rise” in a used bookstore in Raleigh. HAD to buy it!
Tel
March 6, 2010
My decisions are based on the cover artwork.
Just kidding!
I really just peruse the (cyber)aisles, picking up and reading books as I go. Usually, I randomly pick a page and do some reading. If I’m already interested, then I buy it. Sometimes, I read reviews from journals, blogs, or websites that make me want to read the book. However, I never rely on the reviews that are published on the books jackets themselves.
Jessie Carty
March 7, 2010
You bring up a good point, Tel, the whole issue of blurbs. I know a lot of people who put weight on the blurbs but I’ve never decided on a poetry book based on a blurb. I have to open it up and look around
Carter
March 7, 2010
I make an effort to buy books written by people who are my friends on some level even if I don’t particularly care for their work. I buy quite a few books that I find when reading Ron Silliman’s blog and the links he posts on a regular basis. I’ve bought quite a few books, many of them really good, by people who I’ve met on Facebook. (Laura Carter and Joseph Massey come immediately to mind here.)
I, also, do what I’d call quite a bit of catching up. In late 2008/early 2009, I got hung up on The Objectivists and bought what books I could find at a reasonable price by Niedecker, Oppen, Reznikoff, and Rakosi. (I already had the Zukofsky books that were reasonably priced and accessible.)
I don’t think reviews mean much these days particularly in the small press. Though, I do buy books based upon criticism. (The kind I find that is similar to that at JACKET Magazine online.)
jessiecarty
March 7, 2010
Carter – Thanks for stopping by to comment. I think buying books from people I like is the hardest thing for me right now. I have writers I like as people whose work I don’t necessarily like as well and vice versa. Which to buy? Or both?
I’ve found quite a few people to buy books from by way of working on literary magazines.
How do you see criticism as different from reviews? I ask this seriously because I see little in the way of critical writings about contemporary authors anymore. I prefer them as well. Give me some meat about a book instead of just a – I liked it – kind of review.
Thanks, as always, for your thoughts!
valbrussell
March 7, 2010
When I was ten I got my first library card. I went to the middle reader section and because I was overwhelmed with choice, I closed my eyes and pointed. I took the book my finger landed on and it was always interesting and usually a perfect reader/writer fit. I still do it that way in Chapters or the used book store. I also buy books by writers like yourself Ms. Jessie, because when you do make it, I will have a signed copy
Yes, it’s true, I’m a mercenary opportunist that way.
jessiecarty
March 7, 2010
hehe and I have your book you future famous person yourself!
I found the novelist Barbara Kingsolver who I just grew to love and adore in much the way you describe going to the library, Val! I was in junior high and I was really out of wanting to read through the books in the kids section of the library anymore so I was moving into the adult fiction section. I started just going alphabetically through the stacks and when I got to K, I just love the cover of “Bean Trees” so I checked it out.
It wasn’t until years later that I read more of Kingsolver’s work and realized she was like totally famous and all
Feeby
March 9, 2010
For poetry books I have to have read a few reviews. I don’t actively seek poetry books at my local store but if I see one mentioned in a blog I frequent (say this one for example) I usually persue it but I won’t buy it till I’m sure it’s something I’ll enjoy.
For non-fiction I still have to see something about it online but I’m a little less picky. If it even remotely catches my interest from the explanation alone I’m hooked. It takes very little- depending on what it’s about.
For fiction it’s a more elusive process. I walk into the bookstore, head for the genre I’m in the mood for and stand before the shelves like a child at a temple waiting for the gods to speak and speak they do- eventually my eyes catch a shiny cover or some intricate artwork and it’s in my hands before I know. I’m not entirely vain though, the covers catch me but I’m still picky. I read the backs and the first pages and often move on (coming back twice or thrice is a sign I’ll probably buy it in the near future). I also like to work my way through the more obscure books- anything i haven’t heard of or it looks like no one’s given it a good read.
Like I said, an elusive process.
Mwaha, I just signed up on GoodReads. The navigation has already killed me.
jessiecarty
March 9, 2010
GoodReads is slightly addictive! I only use it about once a week to keep from going crazy!!
You can definitely tell which genre you love the most, which one really makes you fall in love